基于群体划分的冠状病毒群体免疫优化算法
|
李博群, 孙志锋
|
A Coronavirus Herd Immunity Optimizer Based on Swarm Division
|
LI Boqun, SUN Zhifeng
|
|
表2 不同元启发式算法的函数测试结果
|
Tab.2 Function test results of different MAs
|
|
函数 | 算法 | μ/A | s/A | 函数 | 算法 | μ/A | s/A | 函数 | 算法 | μ/A | s/A | F1 | PSO | 7.90×10-3 | 1.15×10-2 | F5 | PSO | 5.93×101 | 1.73×101 | F9 | PSO | 2.84×10-2 | 2.04×10-2 | | DE | 5.93×10-4 | 3.42×10-4 | | DE | 1.54×102 | 9.87×100 | | DE | 3.37×10-2 | 6.18×10-2 | | ABC | 2.43×101 | 1.52×101 | | ABC | 2.38×102 | 1.25×101 | | ABC | 1.20×100 | 9.48×10-2 | | WOA | 1.48×10-74 | 6.76×10-74 | | WOA | 3.79×10-15 | 2.08×10-14 | | WOA | 1.12×101 | 3.58×100 | | SSA | 2.45×10-7 | 7.25×10-7 | | SSA | 5.16×101 | 1.68×101 | | SSA | 1.71×10-2 | 1.49×10-2 | | CHIO | 1.21×104 | 3.08×103 | | CHIO | 1.71×102 | 1.75×101 | | CHIO | 1.48×102 | 3.48×101 | | ICHIO | 5.69×10-43 | 1.62×10-43 | | ICHIO | 2.07×102 | 7.68×101 | | ICHIO | 1.28×102 | 2.35×101 | | SD-CHIO | 0 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 0 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 3.76×10-8 | 2.53×10-8 | F2 | PSO | 7.58×100 | 1.79×100 | F6 | PSO | 2.49×10-2 | 1.78×10-2 | F10 | PSO | 2.19×100 | 3.63×100 | | DE | 9.34×100 | 1.81×100 | | DE | 3.44×10-2 | 6.30×10-2 | | DE | 5.98×10-3 | 1.46×10-3 | | ABC | 6.48×101 | 4.07×100 | | ABC | 1.22×100 | 9.54×10-2 | | ABC | 4.15×100 | 3.25×10-1 | | WOA | 4.97×101 | 2.52×101 | | WOA | 8.37×10-3 | 4.59×10-2 | | WOA | 1.56×101 | 1.27×100 | | SSA | 1.25×101 | 3.51×100 | | SSA | 1.64×10-2 | 1.12×10-2 | | SSA | 2.71×100 | 8.22×10-1 | | CHIO | 7.37×101 | 3.41×100 | | CHIO | 1.13×102 | 3.12×101 | | CHIO | 1.73×101 | 7.18×10-1 | | ICHIO | 4.25×10-22 | 9.60×10-23 | | ICHIO | 0 | 0 | | ICHIO | 1.63×101 | 3.05×10-1 | | SD-CHIO | 9.51×10-163 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 0 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 1.88×10-5 | 5.49×10-6 | F3 | PSO | 1.39×100 | 3.45×100 | F7 | PSO | 9.68×10-1 | 1.99×10-1 | F11 | PSO | 1.62×101 | 2.78×100 | | DE | 4.89×10-3 | 1.53×10-3 | | DE | 8.74×10-1 | 1.03×10-1 | | DE | 3.72×101 | 2.25×100 | | ABC | 2.96×10-1 | 7.37×10-2 | | ABC | 3.17×100 | 4.13×10-1 | | ABC | 3.66×101 | 5.15×100 | | WOA | 3.84×10-51 | 1.51×10-50 | | WOA | 1.43×10-1 | 6.26×10-2 | | WOA | 3.14×101 | 2.17×101 | | SSA | 2.08×100 | 1.49×100 | | SSA | 1.90×100 | 4.60×10-1 | | SSA | 1.62×101 | 7.29×100 | | CHIO | 8.19×104 | 4.46×105 | | CHIO | 1.84×101 | 1.30×100 | | CHIO | 7.26×101 | 9.96×100 | | ICHIO | 2.87×10-22 | 4.10×10-23 | | ICHIO | 4.46×10-1 | 5.71×10-2 | | ICHIO | 4.93×101 | 8.15×100 | | SD-CHIO | 4.26×10-164 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 0 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 1.02×101 | 2.81×100 | F4 | PSO | 4.73×10-2 | 1.34×10-2 | F8 | PSO | 5.26×10-1 | 7.42×10-1 | F12 | PSO | 2.99×10-3 | 1.63×10-2 | | DE | 1.60×10-1 | 3.11×10-2 | | DE | 7.47×10-3 | 2.10×10-3 | | DE | 1.39×10-12 | 7.12×10-12 | | ABC | 3.09×10-1 | 8.71×10-2 | | ABC | 4.17×100 | 3.96×10-1 | | ABC | 3.07×10-5 | 5.28×10-5 | | WOA | 3.14×10-3 | 2.68×10-3 | | WOA | 4.09×10-15 | 3.00×10-15 | | WOA | 1.81×100 | 1.60×100 | | SSA | 2.38×10-1 | 9.11×10-2 | | SSA | 2.53×100 | 8.36×10-1 | | SSA | 3.77×10-1 | 4.89×10-1 | | CHIO | 1.36×102 | 1.33×102 | | CHIO | 1.67×101 | 8.05×10-1 | | CHIO | 2.77×100 | 6.26×10-1 | | ICHIO | 1.65×10-3 | 6.31×10-4 | | ICHIO | 1.13×10-14 | 2.94×10-15 | | ICHIO | 1.36×100 | 3.81×10-1 | | SD-CHIO | 1.51×10-4 | 8.50×10-5 | | SD-CHIO | 8.88×10-16 | 0 | | SD-CHIO | 4.90×10-13 | 7.87×10-13 |
|
|
|